You have failed to give us a reason why a completely foreign people to the Middle East – the Ashkenazi – belong in the Middle East? But I also understand why you cannot answer it. You can only say the ridiculous claim that the Ashkenazi are Hebrews or else tell the truth that the Ashkenazi are a European people. But telling the truth would mean that you would have no other way to claim Palestine. What is disgraceful way to live a life always claiming an ancestry and an identity that belong to other people!