For Gilat Shalit, the Palestinians wouldn’t release him unless they got about a thousand terrorists in exchange. Disproportionate?
In the Nusreit raid, Israel lost a soldier, and the Palestinians lost, by their count, 274.
As the Palestinians think 1,000 to 1 in the prisoner Shalit exchange was fair, I will posit that one Israeli soldier killed is disproportionate to only 274 Palestinians getting killed in the Nusreit raid.